Biden Administration Considers HIPAA Update to Better Protect Reproductive Health Information

By | February 21, 2023

The Biden Administration is considering new rulemaking to update HIPAA to better protect reproductive health information, following the Supreme Court Decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which removed the federal right to abortion and left it to individual states to decide on the legality of abortions for state residents. Currently, at least 24 U.S. states have implemented bans on abortions or are likely to do so, with 12 states already having a near-total ban.

The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act classes reproductive health information as protected health information (PHI), so uses and disclosures are restricted by the HIPAA Privacy Rule. Following the Supreme Court decision, the HHS issued guidance to HIPAA-regulated entities on how the HIPAA Privacy Rule applies to reproductive healthcare data, confirming uses and disclosures of reproductive health information are restricted, and that the information can only be used or disclosed without a valid patient authorization for purposes related to treatment, payment, or healthcare operations.

The HHS also confirmed that while the HIPAA Privacy Rule permits disclosures of PHI “as required by law,” the HIPAA Privacy Rule does not require such disclosures, and that ‘required by law’ is limited to “a mandate contained in law that compels an entity to make a use or disclosure of PHI and that is enforceable in a court of law,” an that when such a disclosure is required, it is limited to the relevant requirements of such a law. There is concern, however, that disclosures of reproductive health information may be made by HIPAA-regulated entities to law enforcement in states that have imposed bans or severe restrictions on abortions to support enforcement of the bans and allow individuals seeking abortion care to be prosecuted.

There have been calls for HIPAA to be updated to improve privacy protections with respect to reproductive health information. Currently, there are restrictions on disclosures of certain subclasses of PHI such as psychotherapy notes and information related to substance use disorder (SUD) treatment records, and similar restrictions could potentially be applied to reproductive health information. It has now been confirmed that the Department of Health and Human Services has drafted Proposed Modifications to the HIPAA Privacy Rule to Support Reproductive Health Care Privacy (RIN 0945-AA20), and that proposal is currently under White House review. The HHS has also proposed a change to a rule introduced by the Trump Administration that made it easier for healthcare providers to decline to provide abortions due to religious objections.

The HHS has not released details of the proposed HIPAA update at this stage but has confirmed that prior to drafting the rule, the HHS participated in listening sessions and roundtable discussions with patients, healthcare providers, advocates, and state health officials and that the proposed rule was drafted under its statutory mandate to ensure non-discriminatory access to healthcare for all Americans.

The draft is not necessarily an attempt to impose restrictions on states that have introduced near-total bans on abortions and could be an attempt to ensure any actions by states are compliant with Federal law. It is worth noting that even if the HIPAA Privacy Rule is updated to better protect reproductive health data, HIPAA only applies to HIPAA-regulated entities, and no HIPAA update would be able to guarantee privacy for individuals seeking abortion care. For instance, geolocation data from mobile phones would allow individuals to be tracked when they visit reproductive health clinics.  Geolocation data is not protected by HIPAA and disclosure of such information are not restricted by the HIPAA Privacy Rule.

The post Biden Administration Considers HIPAA Update to Better Protect Reproductive Health Information appeared first on HIPAA Journal.